Free Elections Barred in American Schools? O_o
James Reynolds | January 30, 2009![]()
Gamer, Blogger, Student
James Reynolds
jamesr87[.at.]gmail.com
Blog based on this story.
So here’s a question for you, you’re an American child in an American school. You’re on the Student Council and one of your responsibilities is to communicate information from students to teachers concerning such matters as event days.
But on your liveblog, you call your school administration douchebags for canceling said event and as a result they refuse to let you run for school council again.
Well this is what happened at a Connecticut school and in her appeal against the matter it was deemed that the school board had every right to deny her entry to the election but also that her speech on the liveblog constituted the issuing of disruptive materials INSIDE the school, that being the only place they legally have powers to penalize.
Now there are two problems I have with this story, the first being that in America – The land of the Free – student elections are a privilege given unto a student and in that respect the Schools retain the right to deny people entry to them.
This is in America, a country which has carpet bombed countries for far less. I don’t understand how the School Administration can call themselves Americans and then do something like that, it’s frankly offensive to me as a member of the supposedly free world. One can only wonder how they call themselves Americans.
In that respect, she should be allowed to run, because any election where a party is not allowed to participate – Is not a free election and this event has set a terrible standard and given a horrible impression to these kids on the way Democracy works.
My Second issue is over the use of what she has said off of school premises in punishing her on school premises. After all, she committed no actual crime otherwise she would be on the stand right now. Instead, she voiced a dissenting opinion about the course of action a governing body took and whilst her statement may have been inflammatory there is a difference between filing an official complaint and taking action as a school establishment.
Their decision to punish her basically says “What you say on your Liveblog, is within out jurisdiction” which of course is wholeheartedly untrue.
I hope an appeals court rules in favour of this brave and intelligent young woman, for she understands what it is to be an American. Not … that I do really
Regards,
JamesR.






